volume | PIER Journals

Abstract

Despite the apparent simplicity, the problem of refraction of electromagnetic waves at the planar interface between two media has an incredibly rich spectrum of unusual phenomena. An example is the paradox when an electromagnetic wave impinges on the interface between a hyperbolic medium and an isotropic dielectric. At specific orientations of the optical axis of the hyperbolic medium relative to the interface, the reflected and transmitted waves can can disappear entirely, which contradicts reciprocity. In this paper, we analyze the above mentioned paradox and present its resolution by introducing infinitesimal losses in the hyperbolic medium. We show that the reflected wave exists but becomes ultimately localized at the interface when the losses become vanishing. Consequently, all the energy scattered into the reflected channel is absorbed near the interface. We support our reasoning with analytical calculations, numerical simulations, and an experiment with self-complementary metasurfaces in the microwave range.

1. Bloembergen, Nicolaas and P. S. Pershan, "Light waves at the boundary of nonlinear media," Physical Review, Vol. 128, No. 2, 606-622, Oct. 1962.

2. Lekner, John, "Reflection and refraction by uniaxial crystals," Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, Vol. 3, No. 32, 6121, Aug. 1991.

3. Lekner, John, "Optical properties of isotropic chiral media," Pure and Applied Optics: Journal of the European Optical Society Part A, Vol. 5, No. 4, 417, 1996.

4. Luukkonen, Olli, MÁrio G. Silveirinha, Alexander B. Yakovlev, Constantin R. Simovski, Igor S. Nefedov, and Sergei A. Tretyakov, "Effects of spatial dispersion on reflection from mushroom-type artificial impedance surfaces," IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, Vol. 57, No. 11, 2692-2699, Nov. 2009.

5. Yu, Nanfang, Patrice Genevet, Mikhail A. Kats, Francesco Aieta, Jean-Philippe Tetienne, Federico Capasso, and Zeno Gaburro, "Light propagation with phase discontinuities: Generalized laws of reflection and refraction," Science, Vol. 334, No. 6054, 333-337, Sep. 2011.
doi:10.1126/science.1210713

6. Paniagua-Domínguez, Ramón, Ye Feng Yu, Andrey E. Miroshnichenko, Leonid A. Krivitsky, Yuan Hsing Fu, Vytautas Valuckas, Leonard Gonzaga, Yeow Teck Toh, Anthony Yew Seng Kay, Boris Luk’yanchuk, and Arseniy I. Kuznetsov, "Generalized brewster effect in dielectric metasurfaces," Nature Communications, Vol. 7, No. 1, 10362, Jan. 2016.

7. Yermakov, Oleh, "Shift of Brewster's angle with two-dimensional materials and structures," Physical Review A, Vol. 109, No. 3, L031502, Mar. 2024.

8. Liang, Yao, Kirill Koshelev, Fengchun Zhang, Han Lin, Shirong Lin, Jiayang Wu, Baohua Jia, and Yuri Kivshar, "Bound states in the continuum in anisotropic plasmonic metasurfaces," Nano Letters, Vol. 20, No. 9, 6351-6356, Jun. 2020.

9. Jackson, J. D., Classical Electrodynamics, Wiley, Aug. 1998.

10. Zengerle, R., "Light propagation in singly and doubly periodic planar waveguides," Journal of Modern Optics, Vol. 34, No. 12, 1589-1617, 1987.

11. Gralak, Boris, Stefan Enoch, and Gérard Tayeb, "Anomalous refractive properties of photonic crystals," Journal of the Optical Society of America A, Vol. 17, No. 6, 1012-1020, Jun. 2000.

12. Krishnamoorthy, Harish N. S., Zubin Jacob, Evgenii Narimanov, Ilona Kretzschmar, and Vinod M. Menon, "Topological transitions in metamaterials," Science, Vol. 336, No. 6078, 205-209, Apr. 2012.
doi:10.1126/science.1219171

13. Orlov, Alexey A., Sergei V. Zhukovsky, Ivan V. Iorsh, and Pavel A. Belov, "Controlling light with plasmonic multilayers," Photonics and Nanostructures --- Fundamentals and Applications, Vol. 12, No. 3, 213-230, Jun. 2014.

14. Belov, Pavel A., Constantin R. Simovski, and Pekka Ikonen, "Canalization of subwavelength images by electromagnetic crystals," Physical Review B, Vol. 71, No. 19, 193105, May 2005.

15. Orlov, Alexey A., Pavel M. Voroshilov, Pavel A. Belov, and Yuri S. Kivshar, "Engineered optical nonlocality in nanostructured metamaterials," Physical Review B, Vol. 84, No. 4, 045424, Jul. 2011.

16. He, Mingze, Thomas G. Folland, Jiahua Duan, Pablo Alonso-González, Simone De Liberato, Alexander Paarmann, and Joshua D. Caldwell, "Anisotropy and modal hybridization in infrared nanophotonics using low-symmetry materials," ACS Photonics, Vol. 9, No. 4, 1078-1095, Mar. 2022.

17. Poddubny, Alexander, Ivan Iorsh, Pavel Belov, and Yuri Kivshar, "Hyperbolic metamaterials," Nature Photonics, Vol. 7, No. 12, 948-957, Nov. 2013.

18. Ferrari, Lorenzo, Chihhui Wu, Dominic Lepage, Xiang Zhang, and Zhaowei Liu, "Hyperbolic metamaterials and their applications," Progress in Quantum Electronics, Vol. 40, 1-40, Mar. 2015.

19. Shekhar, Prashant, Jonathan Atkinson, and Zubin Jacob, "Hyperbolic metamaterials: Fundamentals and applications," Nano Convergence, Vol. 1, 1-17, Jun. 2014.

20. Jacob, Zubin, J.-Y. Kim, Gururaj V. Naik, Alexandra Boltasseva, Evgenii E. Narimanov, and Vladimir M. Shalaev, "Engineering photonic density of states using metamaterials," Applied Physics B, Vol. 100, 215-218, Jun. 2010.

21. Poddubny, Alexander N., Pavel A. Belov, and Yuri S. Kivshar, "Spontaneous radiation of a finite-size dipole emitter in hyperbolic media," Physical Review A, Vol. 84, No. 2, 023807, Aug. 2011.

22. Argyropoulos, Christos, Nasim Mohammadi Estakhri, Francesco Monticone, and Andrea Alù, "Negative refraction, gain and nonlinear effects in hyperbolic metamaterials," Optics Express, Vol. 21, No. 12, 15037-15047, Jun. 2013.

23. Liu, Yongmin and Xiang Zhang, "Metasurfaces for manipulating surface plasmons," Applied Physics Letters, Vol. 103, No. 14, 141101, Sep. 2013.

24. High, Alexander A., Robert C. Devlin, Alan Dibos, Mark Polking, Dominik S. Wild, Janos Perczel, Nathalie P. De Leon, Mikhail D. Lukin, and Hongkun Park, "Visible-frequency hyperbolic metasurface," Nature, Vol. 522, No. 7555, 192-196, Jun. 2015.
doi:10.1038/nature14477

25. Gomez-Diaz, J. Sebastian, Mykhailo Tymchenko, and Andrea Alù, "Hyperbolic plasmons and topological transitions over uniaxial metasurfaces," Physical Review Letters, Vol. 114, No. 23, 233901, Jun. 2015.

26. Correas-Serrano, Diego, Andrea Alù, and J. Sebastian Gomez-Diaz, "Plasmon canalization and tunneling over anisotropic metasurfaces," Physical Review B, Vol. 96, No. 7, 075436, Aug. 2017.

27. Yermakov, Oleh, Vladimir Lenets, Andrey Sayanskiy, Juan Baena, Enrica Martini, Stanislav Glybovski, and Stefano Maci, "Surface waves on self-complementary metasurfaces: All-frequency hyperbolicity, extreme canalization, and TE-TM polarization degeneracy," Physical Review X, Vol. 11, No. 3, 031038, Aug. 2021.

28. Takayama, Osamu, Evgeniy Shkondin, Andrey Bodganov, M. Esmail Aryaee Panah, Kirill Golenitskii, Pavel Dmitriev, Taavi Repän, Radu Malureanu, Pavel Belov, Flemming Jensen, and Andrei V. Lavrinenko, "Midinfrared surface waves on a high aspect ratio nanotrench platform," ACS Photonics, Vol. 4, No. 11, 2899-2907, Oct. 2017.

29. Hassani Gangaraj, S. Ali, George W. Hanson, Mário G. Silveirinha, Kunal Shastri, Mauro Antezza, and Francesco Monticone, "Unidirectional and diffractionless surface plasmon polaritons on three-dimensional nonreciprocal plasmonic platforms," Physical Review B, Vol. 99, No. 24, 245414, Jun. 2019.

30. Nemilentsau, Andrei, Tobias Stauber, Guillermo Gómez-Santos, Mitchell Luskin, and Tony Low, "Switchable and unidirectional plasmonic beacons in hyperbolic two-dimensional materials," Physical Review B, Vol. 99, No. 20, 201405, May 2019.

31. Yermakov, O. Y., A. I. Ovcharenko, M. Song, A. A. Bogdanov, I. V. Iorsh, and Yu S. Kivshar, "Hybrid waves localized at hyperbolic metasurfaces," Physical Review B, Vol. 91, No. 23, 235423, Jun. 2015.

32. Yermakov, Oleh Y., Anna A. Hurshkainen, Dmitry A. Dobrykh, Polina V. Kapitanova, Ivan V. Iorsh, Stanislav B. Glybovski, and Andrey A. Bogdanov, "Experimental observation of hybrid TE-TM polarized surface waves supported by a hyperbolic metasurface," Physical Review B, Vol. 98, No. 19, 195404, Nov. 2018.

33. Li, Min, Guangwei Hu, Xuan Chen, Cheng-Wei Qiu, Hongsheng Chen, and Zuojia Wang, "Topologically reconfigurable magnetic polaritons," Science Advances, Vol. 8, No. 50, eadd6660, Dec. 2022.

34. Fang, Nicholas, Hyesog Lee, Cheng Sun, and Xiang Zhang, "Sub-diffraction-limited optical imaging with a silver superlens," Science, Vol. 308, No. 5721, 534-537, Apr. 2005.
doi:10.1126/science.1108759

35. Jacob, Zubin, Leonid V. Alekseyev, and Evgenii Narimanov, "Optical hyperlens: Far-field imaging beyond the diffraction limit," Optics Express, Vol. 14, No. 18, 8247-8256, Sep. 2006.

36. Gomez-Diaz, J. S. and Andrea Alù, "Flatland optics with hyperbolic metasurfaces," ACS Photonics, Vol. 3, No. 12, 2211-2224, Nov. 2016.

37. Sreekanth, K. V., T. Biaglow, and Giuseppe Strangi, "Directional spontaneous emission enhancement in hyperbolic metamaterials," Journal of Applied Physics, Vol. 114, No. 13, 134306, Oct. 2013.

38. Lu, Dylan, Jimmy J. Kan, Eric E. Fullerton, and Zhaowei Liu, "Enhancing spontaneous emission rates of molecules using nanopatterned multilayer hyperbolic metamaterials," Nature Nanotechnology, Vol. 9, No. 1, 48-53, Jan. 2014.

39. Sreekanth, Kandammathe Valiyaveedu, Yunus Alapan, Mohamed ElKabbash, Efe Ilker, Michael Hinczewski, Umut A. Gurkan, Antonio De Luca, and Giuseppe Strangi, "Extreme sensitivity biosensing platform based on hyperbolic metamaterials," Nature Materials, Vol. 15, No. 6, 621-627, Mar. 2016.

40. Sreekanth, Kandammathe Valiyaveedu, Yunus Alapan, Mohamed ElKabbash, Amy M. Wen, Efe Ilker, Michael Hinczewski, Umut A. Gurkan, Nicole F. Steinmetz, and Giuseppe Strangi, "Enhancing the angular sensitivity of plasmonic sensors using hyperbolic metamaterials," Advanced Optical Materials, Vol. 4, No. 11, 1767-1772, Nov. 2016.

41. Shkondin, Evgeniy, Taavi Repän, Mohammad Esmail Aryaee Panah, Andrei V. Lavrinenko, and Osamu Takayama, "High aspect ratio plasmonic nanotrench structures with large active surface area for label-free mid-infrared molecular absorption sensing," ACS Applied Nano Materials, Vol. 1, No. 3, 1212-1218, Feb. 2018.

42. Yermakov, Oleh Y., Anton I. Ovcharenko, Andrey A. Bogdanov, Ivan V. Iorsh, Konstantin Y. Bliokh, and Yuri S. Kivshar, "Spin control of light with hyperbolic metasurfaces," Physical Review B, Vol. 94, No. 7, 075446, Aug. 2016.

43. Mazor, Yarden and Andrea Alù, "Routing optical spin and pseudospin with metasurfaces," Physical Review Applied, Vol. 14, No. 1, 014029, Jul. 2020.

44. Kapitanova, Polina V., Pavel Ginzburg, Francisco J. Rodríguez-Fortuño, Dmitry S. Filonov, Pavel M. Voroshilov, Pavel A. Belov, Alexander N. Poddubny, Yuri S. Kivshar, Gregory A. Wurtz, and Anatoly V. Zayats, "Photonic spin Hall effect in hyperbolic metamaterials for polarization-controlled routing of subwavelength modes," Nature Communications, Vol. 5, No. 1, 3226, Feb. 2014.

45. Takayama, Osamu, Johneph Sukham, Radu Malureanu, Andrei V. Lavrinenko, and Graciana Puentes, "Photonic spin Hall effect in hyperbolic metamaterials at visible wavelengths," Optics Letters, Vol. 43, No. 19, 4602-4605, Oct. 2018.

46. Kim, Minkyung, Dasol Lee, Tae Hak Kim, Younghwan Yang, Hui Joon Park, and Junsuk Rho, "Observation of enhanced optical spin Hall effect in a vertical hyperbolic metamaterial," ACS Photonics, Vol. 6, No. 10, 2530-2536, Sep. 2019.

47. Hu, Guangwei, Alex Krasnok, Yarden Mazor, Cheng-Wei Qiu, and Andrea Alù, "Moiré hyperbolic metasurfaces," Nano Letters, Vol. 20, No. 5, 3217-3224, 2020.

48. Hu, Guangwei, Qingdong Ou, Guangyuan Si, Yingjie Wu, Jing Wu, Zhigao Dai, Alex Krasnok, Yarden Mazor, Qing Zhang, Qiaoliang Bao, Cheng-Wei Qiu, and Andrea Alù, "Topological polaritons and photonic magic angles in twisted α-MoO bilayers," Nature, Vol. 582, No. 7811, 209-213, 2020.
doi:10.1038/s41586-020-2359-9

49. Zhang, Xinyan, Chenxu Bian, Zheng Gong, Ruoxi Chen, Tony Low, Hongsheng Chen, and Xiao Lin, "Hybrid surface waves in twisted anisotropic heterometasurfaces," Physical Review Applied, Vol. 21, No. 6, 064034, 2024.

50. Rustomji, K., R. Abdeddaim, J. Achard, M. Chmiaa, E. Georget, M. Goniche, W. Helou, J. Hillairet, S. Enoch, and G. Tayeb, "Mimicking electromagnetic wave coupling in tokamak plasma with fishnet metamaterials," Scientific Reports, Vol. 8, No. 1, 5841, Apr. 2018.

51. Takayama, Osamu and Andrei V. Lavrinenko, "Optics with hyperbolic materials," Journal of the Optical Society of America B, Vol. 36, No. 8, F38-F48, Aug. 2019.

52. Guo, Zhiwei, Haitao Jiang, and Hong Chen, "Hyperbolic metamaterials: From dispersion manipulation to applications," Journal of Applied Physics, Vol. 127, No. 7, 071101, Feb. 2020.

53. Caldwell, Joshua D., Andrey V. Kretinin, Yiguo Chen, Vincenzo Giannini, Michael M. Fogler, Yan Francescato, Chase T. Ellis, Joseph G. Tischler, Colin R. Woods, Alexander J. Giles, Minghui Hong, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Stefan A. Maier, and Kostya S. Novoselov, "Sub-diffractional volume-confined polaritons in the natural hyperbolic material hexagonal boron nitride," Nature Communications, Vol. 5, No. 1, 5221, Oct. 2014.

54. Nemilentsau, Andrei, Tony Low, and George Hanson, "Anisotropic 2D materials for tunable hyperbolic plasmonics," Physical Review Letters, Vol. 116, No. 6, 066804, Feb. 2016.

55. Dai, Siyuan, Mykhailo Tymchenko, Yafang Yang, Qiong Ma, Marta Pita-Vidal, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Pablo Jarillo-Herrero, Michael M. Fogler, Andrea Alù, and Dimitri N. Basov, "Manipulation and steering of hyperbolic surface polaritons in hexagonal boron nitride," Advanced Materials, Vol. 30, No. 16, 1706358, Apr. 2018.

56. Li, Peining, Irene Dolado, Francisco Javier Alfaro-Mozaz, F. Casanova, Luis E. Hueso, Song Liu, James H. Edgar, Alexey Y. Nikitin, S. Vélez, and Rainer Hillenbrand, "Infrared hyperbolic metasurface based on nanostructured van der Waals materials," Science, Vol. 359, No. 6378, 892-896, Feb. 2018.
doi:10.1126/science.aaq1704

57. Wang, Hongwei, Yuhan Zhong, Wei Jiang, Simone Latini, Shengxuan Xia, Tian Cui, Zhenglu Li, Tony Low, and Feng Liu, "Strain-tunable hyperbolic exciton polaritons in monolayer black arsenic with two exciton resonances," Nano Letters, Vol. 24, No. 6, 2057-2062, 2024.

58. Yermakov, Oleh Y., Dmitry V. Permyakov, Filipp V. Porubaev, Pavel A. Dmitriev, Anton K. Samusev, Ivan V. Iorsh, Radu Malureanu, Andrei V. Lavrinenko, and Andrey A. Bogdanov, "Effective surface conductivity of optical hyperbolic metasurfaces: From far-field characterization to surface wave analysis," Scientific Reports, Vol. 8, No. 1, 14135, Sep. 2018.

59. Guo, Zhiwei, Haitao Jiang, and Hong Chen, "Abnormal wave propagation in tilted linear-crossing metamaterials," Advanced Photonics Research, Vol. 2, No. 1, 2000071, Jan. 2021.

60. He, Zhiwei, Huaping Wang, Zhenyang Cui, Sihao Xia, Xingyu Tang, Bin Zheng, Xiao Lin, Lian Shen, Hongsheng Chen, and Yingjie Wu, "Reflectionless refraction via one-dimensional ghost polaritons in planar junctions of hyperbolic metasurfaces," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 181, 1-8, 2024.

61. Dai, Zhigao, Guangwei Hu, Guangyuan Si, Qingdong Ou, Qing Zhang, Sivacarendran Balendhran, Fahmida Rahman, Bao Yue Zhang, Jian Zhen Ou, Guogang Li, Andrea Alù, Cheng-Wei Qiu, and Qiaoliang Bao, "Edge-oriented and steerable hyperbolic polaritons in anisotropic van der Waals nanocavities," Nature Communications, Vol. 11, No. 1, 6086, Nov. 2020.

Dr. Ilya Deriy

Dr. Kseniia Lezhennikova

Dr. Stanislav B. Glybovski

Dr. Ivan Iorsh

Dr. Oleh Y. Yermakov

Mr. Mingzhao Song

Dr. Redha Abdeddaim

Dr. Stefan Enoch

Dr. Pavel A. Belov

Prof. Andrey A. Bogdanov